The 43k on the speedometer looks about right.  This might be a good price.

“Jeep Willys with custom top. This jeep sat in a dry garage since 1985 when the inspection ran out. No title, but I have the info to apply for it. Restoration project 4×4, 4 cylinder, Manual, Odometer reads 43k miles.  Asking $1,000 or make offer.  Serious inquiries only please.  If you are reading this than it is still available. Thanx Rob 577 8965.”

http://york.craigslist.org/cto/1451965888.html

It needs a starter (according to the seller), but is otherwise good (well, at least that is implied).  The price seems right.

“1957 willys jeep cj5 has a small block 350,dana axles 3 speed willys tranny lift kit supper swampers spare to match 30×9.5 50r15 has 570 miles on jeep sents been built just needs a starter to run also comes with a high lift jack and a big winch on the front any questions on it call brian at 801-598-8757 looking to get 1500.00 obo”

http://saltlakecity.craigslist.org/cto/1440393059.html

It runs and has a lunar seat in back.

“This is a good hunting jeep. I got the jeep in a trade and know little about it. Has 4cyl. flathead. 4×4 works smokes a little and needs brake work. Coated inside and out. Will try to get other info if needed, just ask or call. Thanks!”

http://www.free-jeep-classifieds.com/classifieds/XcCPViewItem.asp?id=2470

It’s rough, but runs.

“1956 WILLYS JEEP RUNS GOOD, ALL THE WARREN 4X4 RUNNING GEAR IN GOOD OPERATING CONDITION, BRAKES NEED WORK . FOR SALE OR POSSIBLE TRADE. $1500.00 CALL ANYTIME, LEAVE A MESSAGE OR AFTER 3:30 OR ANY TIME ON THE WEEK-END IF YOU WANT TO TALK TO SOMEONE. 360-775-7546”

http://olympic.craigslist.org/cto/1432789249.html

UPDATE:  **SOLD** Was $6300

This a beautiful jeep with a most unusual feature:  The body is aluminum.http://www.ewillys.com/wp-admin/post-new.php

“FRAME OFF RESTORED….2361 MILES SINCE COMPLETED…V-6 3 SPEED MANUAL 4WD…CAN BE SEEN AT RIVER BENZ MOTORS.

UPDATE: **SOLD** Was $1500.

“Selling an all original 1960s Willys Jeep. Has an L-134 engine, T-90 transmission, Dana 18 twin stick transfer case and warn locking hubs. It runs good and is in fair shape. Asking 2000 or obo.”