Once you’ve decided that Craigslist, ebay and the local junkyards can’t supply all your parts needs, you’ll likely have to turn to suppliers of new parts or suppliers of jeep specific parts. I hope this list is helpful. Some are small and some are big. This list is by no means exhaustive, so please feel free to send me your favorites.
NEW: Try this — I did a search on a “CJ-5 gas tank” and stumbled across a website called “The Find“. It had search results from Tellico, zaib4x4, 4 wheel parts, and a variety of others. So, I did a few more searches. It looks like a great way to compare online prices. They have an iphone app as well.
KaiserWillys.com – KaiserWillys has been selling vintage Jeep and Willys parts for over 10 years. All parts are either NOS (New Old Stock) or new replacement unless otherwise specified.
Peter Debella Jeep Parts. Peter has decades of experience with jeeps and a massive collection of rare military parts. If you can’t find it or are not sure what you are looking for, give him a call.
Tellico 4×4 – Tellico 4×4 has been online since 1999. Located in Colorado, there online site serves national and international customers. I’ve ordered some parts from them without issue. My only issue is that the one catalog I’ve received didn’t have prices.
Willys America – Located along the Russian River in Cazadero, California, Willys America offers parts and restoration services for Willys Enthusiasts.
Bodies and more:
MD Juan – This body manufacturer from the Philippines makes all kinds of bodies.
Classic Enterprises Restoration: Manufactures body parts for several different jeep models.
Malotte Mfg – Makers of fiberglass bodies (CJ-2A, CJ-3A, M-38, CJ-5 & CJ-7). They carry one piece shells, one piece fronts, race and street body editions, individual fenders, hoods and grilles, and some uniquely styled pieces.
US Body Source – (after clicking on link, scroll down the long menu on the website’s left hand side) This company sells fiberglass parts. The body style is unique. The company sells a jeep hood to which you can add, for $50 more, your choice of a hood scoop from many different hood scoops. One other unique item is a CJ-3A windshield skin.
Aqualu – If you want an aluminum body for your CJ-2A, CJ-3A or CJ-5, you can get it here.
Other parts sellers:
Summit Racing – Plenty of jeep and non-jeep parts. I’ve made several orders. I got a free hat.
Doug Herbert – Doug Herbert’s inventory is slightly different than summit racing. I purchased a Griffin Radiator through them because it was approx $30 cheaper than Summit. They’ve got a great catalog as well.
4WheelerSupply – Missouri 4Wheelers Supply, LLC (4WheelersSupply.com) has been in business since 2001 and has continued to grow by leaps and bounds. They are currently a W/D distributor for Superlift, Skyjacker, Rubicon Express, Corbeau, Mile Marker, Auburn Gear, Crow, Pit Bull Tires, Select Increments and Tuffy Security Products. They have a variety of parts for a variety of jeeps.
JC Whitney – JC Whitney supplies a wide range of parts for all kinds of vehicles. Their prices seem reasonable and their list of jeep parts seems pretty extensive.