The 43k on the speedometer looks about right.  This might be a good price.

“Jeep Willys with custom top. This jeep sat in a dry garage since 1985 when the inspection ran out. No title, but I have the info to apply for it. Restoration project 4×4, 4 cylinder, Manual, Odometer reads 43k miles.  Asking $1,000 or make offer.  Serious inquiries only please.  If you are reading this than it is still available. Thanx Rob 577 8965.”

http://york.craigslist.org/cto/1451965888.html

It needs a starter (according to the seller), but is otherwise good (well, at least that is implied).  The price seems right.

“1957 willys jeep cj5 has a small block 350,dana axles 3 speed willys tranny lift kit supper swampers spare to match 30×9.5 50r15 has 570 miles on jeep sents been built just needs a starter to run also comes with a high lift jack and a big winch on the front any questions on it call brian at 801-598-8757 looking to get 1500.00 obo”

http://saltlakecity.craigslist.org/cto/1440393059.html

It runs and has a lunar seat in back.

“This is a good hunting jeep. I got the jeep in a trade and know little about it. Has 4cyl. flathead. 4×4 works smokes a little and needs brake work. Coated inside and out. Will try to get other info if needed, just ask or call. Thanks!”

http://www.free-jeep-classifieds.com/classifieds/XcCPViewItem.asp?id=2470

It’s rough, but runs.

“1956 WILLYS JEEP RUNS GOOD, ALL THE WARREN 4X4 RUNNING GEAR IN GOOD OPERATING CONDITION, BRAKES NEED WORK . FOR SALE OR POSSIBLE TRADE. $1500.00 CALL ANYTIME, LEAVE A MESSAGE OR AFTER 3:30 OR ANY TIME ON THE WEEK-END IF YOU WANT TO TALK TO SOMEONE. 360-775-7546”

http://olympic.craigslist.org/cto/1432789249.html

UPDATE:  **SOLD** Was $6300

This a beautiful jeep with a most unusual feature:  The body is aluminum.http://www.ewillys.com/wp-admin/post-new.php

“FRAME OFF RESTORED….2361 MILES SINCE COMPLETED…V-6 3 SPEED MANUAL 4WD…CAN BE SEEN AT RIVER BENZ MOTORS.

UPDATE: **SOLD** Was $1500.

“Selling an all original 1960s Willys Jeep. Has an L-134 engine, T-90 transmission, Dana 18 twin stick transfer case and warn locking hubs. It runs good and is in fair shape. Asking 2000 or obo.”

UPDATE:  Price dropped to $700

(10/06/09) This looks like a great price for 2 parts jeeps.  The cage alone is worth $100+

“this is 2 jeeps the red one has orignal paint i was told it was running when parked but now the engine is stuck and the other jeep also has a engine that is not stuck they are bolth orignal engines but its missing some parts you can make one good jeep thanks frank 707-484-5251”

http://sfbay.craigslist.org/nby/cto/1409887961.html

UPDATE: **SOLD** Was $2200.

Apparently, the Transfer Case could use some work.  Otherwise, this looks like a good price for this CJ.

“1964 jeep cj5 , 4 cil ,4 spd trans,engine is in top condition starts right up,but it does need transfer case work.”

The seller refers to this as a project, but then says this runs and drives great.  Given this has a Warn OD, this looks to be a great price.

“It has a 231 buick v6, stock 3 speed trans, Warn overdrive on transfer case. Body is in good condition, has carpet kit in all of tub. Diamond plate rockers and side armor. Good deal, I have too many projects and cant get to this. Runs and drives great. Call me David (509) 590-7764”

http://spokane.craigslist.org/cto/1417355906.html

A nice roll cage, a brand new winch, and a clean look body make this appear to be a good deal.

“i am selling a 57 jeep cj 5, body and frame are very solid. runs perfect, brand new winch hardly used. has lots of new parts. brand new tires, new springs. new carb. any questions call 998-4984.”

http://nh.craigslist.org/cto/1408874989.html

This is a project, but sounds like a good foundation for a road/trail jeep.  it includes an over drive an Dana 30 with an ARB Locker.

“1963 Willys CJ5 with a rebuilt 1978 Buick 231 V6 backed by a rebuilt T18 4 sp with OD. Has Model 44 rear end with 4:27 gears Power Lock locker and Model 25 front same gear and locker. Comes with extra Model 25 and a Model 30 with ARB Air Locker. Tub was removed sandblasted, repaired and primed. New wiring kit needs to be put on has a Brand new Best Top soft top and 31×10.5×15 about 95% and many extras. This is a ground up restoration just need to complete. Medical condition prevents me from finishing this off everything is here just need to put it together. This is a full deal I will not part out so please don’t ask. CALL 253-845-1301 for more details or to make appt. look at.”

http://seattle.craigslist.org/tac/cto/1406321529.html

This includes an overdrive, but it’s still a project.  The seller is moving.

“This jeep would make a great hunting,wheeling or restoration.has 4″rancho suspension lift,shackle lift,almost brand new 34X10.50 super swampers and wheels,warn over drive worth 6-$800.00 alone,bed lined inside tub.engine is a buick 231 oddfire v-6 runs great.Needs windsheild bolted back on, and some electrical work head lights tail lights and the roll cage needs bolted back in seats not in picture but now in jeep. moving soon must sell $2,000”

http://seattle.craigslist.org/oly/cto/1404363606.html

This looks like a good price.

“4 cyl,3 spd,warn overdrive can be used in any gear including reverse,power steering,full roll cage,tow bar,reverse and side light.used twice a year for hunting.slight hood damage.call carlos for detail’s at 1-520-777-0670.”

http://tucson.craigslist.org/cto/1401621211.html

UPDATE: **SOLD** Was on eBay.

“Very nice!!!!! 1965 Tuxedo Park Mark IV CJ5 jeep.  This is a very nice  Jeep with a $4500.00 paint job and new tires.The motor is new rebuilt with about 1000 miles on it. Runs very smoth and strong with now drivetrain noise. The paint is very detailed on the floor bord, dash, and rims. The seats are camo with three pont set belt with warn hubs”

Hey, this looks very nice for only $1500.  This assumes “needs a little work” really means little work.

“1963 Willys CJ-5 F-Head 4-cyl.; replaced exhust to specs., fuel tank,some odds & end stuff. the floor pans have some sheet metal patches from the previouse owner. needs a little work.seats are not stock.and could use body bushings. frame is ok. I had this insp. a few years ago, then used it on my farm. Good easy restoration project. not a highway runner. serious buyers only…..NO Tire Kickers….
$1500. Firm… call to get location to see. Thanks, Chris …  Cell# (610)468-6004”

http://reading.craigslist.org/cto/1395024334.html

UPDATE: **SOLD** Was $1500

It doesn’t run, but it looks in reasonable shape.

“This jeep needs total restoration. we are asking just what we have invested in the engine rebuild and new tires. original manual and about 20 other manuals with new gas cans and containers rough condition outside, only has about 400 miles on rebuilt engine 2.2L, Red with hardtop, 1960 CJ5 Willys Jeep doesn’t run currently needs carburator rebuilt using either the old or new one, have lots of extras, all original paperwork, reciepts for engine and new tires.”